Studies

1. Street lighting impact on environment, animal life

2. Light pollution and glare in street lighting

3. Photopic and scotopic vision

 

 

1. STREET LIGHTING IMPACT ON ENVIRONMENT, ANIMAL LIFE

Studies in Europe have demonstrated that streetlighting has a significant effect on the mood of human beings, animal life and the environment. It affects navigation of birds and insects, mating behavior in animals and flowering in plants. Millions of insects are attracted to street lights at night (par

 

ticularly during summer months) and perish. These insects can be an urban nuisance besides adding to the cost of cleaning up lamp fixtures and the street sidewalk to remove dead insects. But not all street lights attract insects or affect animal life the same. The impact of LED lights on animals is much smaller compared to other lights.

 

 

 

 

 

 

2. LIGHT POLLUTION AND GLARE IN STREET LIGHTING

 

IESNA classifies luminaires as »non cutoff«, »semi cutoff«, »cutoff« and »full cutoff«, depending on how much of light is dispersed above the horizontal line of luminaire.

 

Non-cutoff

The non-cutoff fixtures usually include the globe-shaped lamps that are mounted on top of lampposts. These lamps distribute their light in all directions. A major problem is created by the light pollution and glare, as they shoot their light upwards into trees and towards the sky rather than down towards the ground. Non-cutoff fixtures are rarely found on roadways because they tend to blind the driver.

 

 

Semicutoff

This is the most popular street lighting optic. The semicutoff fixtures usually refer to the cobraheads, but they can also apply to some lamppost-mounted fixtures that do not emit their light upwards. Most of the light can be emitted below 90 degrees, but as much as 5% of the light can also be emitted above 90 degrees. These fixtures do a very good job of spreading the light towards the ground but some uplight is possible, though not as serious as non-cutoff fixtures. Semicutoff fixtures are often mounted on tall poles.

 

 

 

 

Cutoff

These optics give more light control than semicutoffs. Less than 2.5% of the light can leave the fixture above 90 degrees. Cutoff fixtures have gained popularity in recent years, as they are available from manufacturers like GE and American Electric. The cutoff lights have a wider spread of light than full-cutoffs, and they generate less glare than semicutoffs. The cutoff lenses consist of a shallow curved glass (also called a sag lens) that is visible just below the lighting area on the fixture.

 

 

 

Full-cutoff

These lights do not allow any of the light to escape the fixture above 90 degrees. Full-cutoffs distribute their light in a defined pattern, potentially providing more light on the ground at lower power consumption. Full cutoff means luminaires which are totally environmentally friendly (causing no light pollution).

 

 

 

 

 

3. PHOTOPIC AND SCOTOPIC VISION

 

An understanding of the concept of Scotopic lumens can deeply influence cost and performance equations of lighting solutions.

Scotopic lumen output depends not only on the absolute light output from a lamp but also on the wavelengths comprising light from a light source. Human eye has two kinds of light sensing cells – Rods and Cones, which both have different spectral sensitivities. Line of sight vision is due largely to cone cells. Peripheral vision on the other hand is affected by rod cells.

 

Human vision is therefore enabled by three primary modes:

• Photopic vision: Vision under well-lit conditions, which provides for color perception, and which functions primarily due to cone cells in the eye.
• Mesopic vision: A combination of photopic vision and scotopic vision in low lighting, which functions due to a combination of rod and cone cells in the eye.
• Scotopic vision: Monochromatic vision in very low light, which functions primarily due to rod cells in the eye.

 

Although all three modes of vision help us see under different conditions, nighttime vision is generally dominated by scotopic mechanisms (for very dark conditions with no ambient light) or mesopic mechanisms (for semi-dark conditions, such as a full moon and heavily lit commercial roadways). Unfortunately, virtually all photometric tests used to determine light output from street lighting sources are based on photopic vision, which is not representative of the human response to light under low light (nighttime) conditions. Photopic measurements favor “warmer” light, such as the orange light produced by common HID street light sources, including high pressure sodium lamps. Scotopic and mesopic measurements are more representative of a broader spectrum of light, including the “cooler” light generated by most LEDs used in street lighting applications.Because of these differences, many leading scientists and lighting experts believe that photopic measurements should be used for daytime and indoor lighting measurements, and scotopic or mesopic measurements should be used to evaluate nighttime lighting measurements.

 

The Illuminating Engineering Society of North America (IESNA)—which currently uses photopic measurement criteria for evaluating street lights—is currently reviewing the photopic versus scotopic/mesopic measurement issue, and revised street light standards are expected to be issued from the IESNA in the near future. In the meantime, many LED users are evaluating light output based using both photopic and scotopic measurements. Since most photometry is based on photopic measurements, a scientific conversion factor is used to create scotopic measurements from photopic measurement data.

Scientists at the Lawrence Berkley Laboratory (LBL) developed a factor called P/S ratio. This ratio helps convert traditional lumens into actual lumens perceived by the eye under mesopic light conditions and gives a more accurate estimate of the amount of light.

 

 

 

Pupil Lumens = Photopic Lumens * [S/P] 0.78

Here are some types of lights with their traditional and pupil lumens

Source of light	Watt	Lumens	Lumens/Watt (Photopic lumens)	S/P ratio (correction factor)	Pupil lumens	Pupil lumens/watt
Low pressure sodium	250	32500	130	0.2	9250	37
High pressure sodium	365	37000	101	0.62	25530	70
Metal Halide	455	36000	79	1.49	48960	108
T8 fluorescent (3000K)	36	2800	78	1.13	3080	85
LED light	15	1500	100	1.9	2475	165

 

Factoring in the scotopic efficiency of lamps demonstrates that LED lights outperform most other technologies by 100 % or more.

 

Example

 

 

The road on the left is illuminated with LED lights and that on the right with High pressure Sodium (HPS) lamps. LED lights produce less lumens as compared to the HPS lamp but visibility is better under LED lights. This is because of better color rendering index, light uniformity and scotopic efficiency.